ABSTRACT: JOHN PAUL YOUNG 2025

(Note: If this were an actual academic or legal submission, citations from case law, human rights reports, and legal studies on wrongful prosecution would be included.)

John Paul Young: A Case Study in Judicial Misconduct, Artistic Resilience, and the Quest for Justice


Abstract


This paper examines the life and career of John Paul Young, a Canadian artist known for his contributions to music and film, whose professional trajectory was irrevocably altered by a protracted legal ordeal stemming from judicial misconduct, malicious prosecution, and systemic failure. This case study details Young’s rise to prominence in the 1970s and 1980s as a musician, actor, and voice artist, his catastrophic fall into homelessness and repeated false imprisonment, and his ongoing efforts to reclaim his legacy and pursue legal redress. Through an analytical lens, we explore the interplay between systemic abuse of power, legal recourse, and the resilience required to survive prolonged institutionalized injustice.

Introduction


John Paul Young emerged as a pivotal figure in the Canadian punk and alternative music scenes under the moniker Cardboard Brains, a band he founded in the late 1970s. Recognized for his vocal and theatrical prowess, Young was awarded the CASBY Award for Most Promising Male Recording Artist in 1982 for his solo album The Life of Ermie Scub. His reputation extended beyond music into film and voice acting, securing work in productions such as Johnny Mnemonic (1996), where he contributed voice performances.


However, in 2001, Young’s career and personal stability were catastrophically disrupted by a series of legal entanglements stemming from what he asserts was judicial misconduct, orchestrated to undermine and erase his professional standing. Over the next decade, he would be subjected to multiple unlawful arrests, imprisonment, and systemic harassment, culminating in years of homelessness and destitution. This paper traces Young’s efforts to document his legal history, seek justice, and rebuild his career while navigating the enduring psychological and financial toll of these experiences.

I. The Rise: A Career in Music and Film


Young’s early career trajectory reflected a dynamic intersection of punk, alternative, and avant-garde influences. His band Cardboard Brains released several vinyl records that gained recognition within Canada’s underground music scene and beyond. His 1980 solo album demonstrated his versatility as an artist, earning him critical recognition.


Beyond music, Young leveraged his vocal talents in the film industry, earning ACTRA membership under the professional reputation clause. His voice work and ability as a mimic became his primary artistic tools, expanding his professional reach. However, these achievements would soon be overshadowed by an extralegal campaign that systematically dismantled his livelihood.

II. The Fall: Systemic Abuse, Judicial Misconduct, and Erasure


In 2001, Young became entangled in a series of legal actions that he attributes to a targeted effort to discredit and destroy his career. The allegations against him led to multiple arrests, none of which were based on legitimate grounds. Instead, he contends that they were the result of a collusion between law enforcement, judicial actors, and personal adversaries, including his father and a former family doctor.


Between 2002 and 2012, Young faced repeated harassment and imprisonment, experiences that compounded his trauma and directly contributed to his descent into homelessness. The prolonged legal battles deprived him of access to evidence, professional resources, and financial stability, leading to a decade of enforced anonymity and hardship.


Young’s case exhibits characteristics of a wrongful prosecution, including:

1. Malicious Prosecution: Persistent legal action against an individual without probable cause, intended to inflict harm.

2. Judicial Misconduct: Evidence tampering, perjury, and complicity of legal actors in enabling unlawful incarceration.

3. Human Rights Violations: Systematic targeting that deprived him of fundamental freedoms, professional opportunities, and dignity.


Despite repeated attempts to clear his name, Young found himself trapped within a legal system that failed to acknowledge the abuses against him. In 2012, he fled Toronto for Halifax, where he has since lived in relative peace but remains financially destitute and professionally sidelined.

III. The Present: Seeking Justice and Rebuilding a Legacy


Now 68, Young is actively pursuing legal redress through Freedom of Information (FOI) requests and legal research. His primary objectives include:

• Compiling Documentation: Retrieving police records, court documents, and evidence to construct an irrefutable case of malicious prosecution.

• Legal Advocacy: Seeking legal representation to file claims for damages, personal injury, and human rights violations.

• Public Awareness: Leveraging digital platforms, including his forthcoming website johnpaulyoung.ca, to restore his public profile and engage with audiences who once followed his work.


In addition to legal efforts, Young is working to regain his artistic voice. He has explored avenues such as voiceover work, online platforms like Fiverr and Upwork, and potential busking as a means to reacclimate to public performance. Despite severe financial and psychological setbacks, he remains intent on reclaiming the reputation and livelihood that were unjustly stripped from him.

IV. The Larger Implications: A Case for Legal Reform


Young’s case is not an isolated incident but part of a broader pattern of systemic legal abuses in Canada and beyond. His experiences illustrate the following key issues:

1. Judicial Accountability: The absence of oversight mechanisms that allow wrongful arrests and prosecutions to go unchallenged.

2. Effects of Legal System Failures on Mental Health: The compounding effects of trauma resulting from false imprisonment, police harassment, and defamation.

3. The Role of Public Perception in Legal Abuses: How public narratives around an individual’s downfall can be manipulated to obscure state and institutional misconduct.


Legal scholars, human rights advocates, and those involved in wrongful conviction research may find Young’s case an instructive example of how the legal system can be weaponized against individuals who lack financial or institutional power.

Conclusion


John Paul Young’s story is one of both immense talent and immense loss—of a career interrupted, a reputation tarnished, and years of his life spent battling an invisible but omnipresent adversary: institutional corruption. His current pursuit of legal justice and professional revival represents not only a deeply personal struggle but a broader indictment of the failures of the Canadian legal system.


This case study underscores the urgent need for legal reform, systemic accountability, and support mechanisms for individuals victimized by judicial misconduct. If Young’s efforts succeed, they may not only restore his own legacy but also serve as a precedent for others seeking justice after systemic abuse.


Young’s fight is ongoing. His website, legal campaign, and return to artistic endeavors will determine whether he can reclaim what was lost—or whether the weight of institutionalized injustice proves insurmountable.


References


(Note: If this were an actual academic or legal submission, citations from case law, human rights reports, and legal studies on wrongful prosecution would be included.)


This blog provides me with a forum to share my music, films, writing, photographs and musings. Currently in absence of any product or project to promote it’s a great platform to connect with fans and friends after a too long twenty year hiatus. Flow of consciousness postings, seemingly disconnected sometimes, eventually make sense when viewed as a whole.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

KIDNAPPED!

Image
  I’m just saying    The original intent of this post is to address my kidnapping, robbery, and attempted murder on Yorkville Avenue in Toronto, which occurred on July 2, 2002, at 6:55 PM in broad daylight. I intend to delve into this event in great detail shortly. Regarding my book, whether it's memoirs or an autobiography, there's a lot to discuss in an overview before I delve into specifics. On Wikipedia's "CARDBOARD BRAINS" page, it once stated that "John Paul Young is currently in seclusion," or in other words, hermitage. Although it has been edited out, it was essentially accurate.   I have been in seclusion since September 2002. My whereabouts and contact information were unknown, which was my preference. Consequently, when Cardboard Brains performed at the Horseshoe Tavern for THE LAST POGO JUMPS AGAIN in 2007, Cardboard Brains guitarist had his friend and former Cardboard Brains member John "Sandy" McFadyen step in as the front man-voc...
Read more

I WANT TO BE A YANK WITH LYRICS

Image
  I Want To Be A Yank This of course is the 1977 iconic CARDBOARD BRAINS White EP with I Want To Be A Yank, Living Inside My Head, Can Stress Kill, and of course our pre-pistols cover of the Monkees (I’m not your) Stepping Stone. The Canadian punk outfit FUCKED UP did a successful cover of I Want To Be A Yank, however the lyrics aren’t correct. So I would like to take this opportunity to present them in their full glory. “WHO REALLY CARES ABOUT MAGGIE T.? I’M REALLY SICK OF THE CBC. THE KIDS ARE ROTTING AT U. Of T. JUST TO WORK FOR THE U.I.C. RENE LEVESQUE’S THE MISSING LINK CBC TV PROGRAMS REALLY STINK YOUR MONEYS ALL DOWN THE DRINK I WISH I DIDN’T HAVE TO THINK. U.S. THEY GOT TAINTED HAM U.S. THEY GOT SON OF SAM U.S. THEY GOT SIRHAN SIRHAN U.S. THEY GOT VIETNAM I WANT TO BE A YANK! WHO REALLY CARES ABOUT MAGGIE T.? I’M REALLY SICK OF THE CBC THE KIDS ARE ROTTING AT U.of T. JUST TO WORK FOR THE U.I.C. U.S. THEY GOT JIMMY CARTER U.S. YOU CAN BE A MARTYR U.S. THEY GOT WORLD SERIES U...
Read more

CINOFRENIC (1978)

Image
 This is in response to a comment by unknown. I “star” in CINOFRENIC, as “Paul”. To the best of my knowledge Cardboard Brains does not perform in the film but Mike Nightmare and The Ugly does. I think The B-Girls also perform, and I can’t remember who else does. I probably wasn’t there that day. IMDB probably has more info on CINOFRENIC. Vince Carlucci would remember if Cardboard Brains performed in the film. I’m occasionally asked about it and if a copy is available. Again I don’t know. Eventually one will surface. Apparently it’s got some good footage of bands like The Ugly. I will always remember seeing Mike Nightmare spinning his mic around and singing: “Your not living in the real world!”. RIP Mike Nightmare. Thanks for the comment. JPY . And no, I don’t perform any music in the film. However we did in The Gate (1986). More about that shortly.
Read more

GET UP STAND UP STAND UP FOR YOUR RIGHTS!

Image
I wrote the last blog early in the morning, feeling terribly ill, which explains all the typos and such. One day, I intend to edit all of it, but for now, I'm just glad to have some material published. It's material that's difficult for me to discuss, yet it's something I constantly think about. However, I find it cathartic to share it on a public online forum. I touched upon my brother's death to some extent, though not completely. Honestly, I'd prefer not to delve into it, but I find it necessary. I felt compelled to mention discovering my brother's body to provide context to the series of events that impacted my nuclear family: the subsequent passing of my mother, my abduction, my seven baseless arrests, and four unjust incarcerations. Not to mention, enduring ten years on the harsh streets of Toronto while being swindled out of approximately fifteen million dollars in cash and assets. The "sick as a dog" episode began with a tickle in my throat...
Read more

KIDNAPPED! (Continued)…Yorkville, Toronto

Image
I come from a family of four: my mother, Margaret Isabel Young (née Peace), my father, Dr. Robert Goddard Young, my brother, William Robert Stuart Young, who was six years my junior, and myself, John Paul Young. My brother's untimely death in July 1996 occurred just as I was about to turn forty. For the next six years, I took on the role of primary caregiver for my parents. The grim discovery of my younger brother's body in his apartment shocked me profoundly. The officer on duty, "Bart," suggested at the scene that by identifying my brother's body for the Coroner, I could shield our elderly parents from the anguish of seeing their son in such a condition. In clinical shock, I waited for the Coroner, a compassionate woman who arrived with the others. She understood the emotional impact of identifying a deceased relative, particularly given the condition of his body after two days. I wasn't allowed to see my brother's body until the Coroner deemed it approp...
Read more

The Sun Still Shines

Image
  The Boulevards of Hope. You know, Dear Friends, what I really would like to do is release new music. But financing a project is the problem. If I were to use Ermie Scub as a guideline, it would cost about $CDN50,000.00 to release a comparable LP. Plus promotion and distribution. And I need things such as a practice space and gear. Maybe I will win the lottery or get a Canada Council for the Arts grant. Many sources including the CBC and Nardwaur and Canadian Composer (which was in the days of CAPAC) have commented on how depressing and down it is. But I submit that the above track is optimistic. And it’s one of my fave tracks on The Life of Ermie Scub.
Read more